الرواة الذين أطلق الإمام الذهبي فيهم الخلاف ولم يقض فيهم بشيء في كتابه الكاشف من بداية: مَن اسمه إبراهيم إلى نهاية مَن اسمه عثمان

- جمعًا ودراسةً -

The narrators about whom Imam Al-Dhahabi raised disagreements and did not rule anything about them in his book Al-Kashif From the beginning of his name Ibrahim to the end of his name Othman

- plural and study -

يُعنى هذا البحث بجمع ودراسة الرواة الذين حكى الإمام الذهبي فيهم خلاف من تقدمه من أئمة الجرح والتعديل ولم يبين حكمه النهائي فيهم في كتابه الكاشف في معرفة من له رواية في الكتب الستة، والخروج بنتيجة نهائية في هؤلاء الرواة، وقد بلغ عددهم في هذا الجزء من البحث عشرين راويًا.

الكلمات المفتاحية: (الذهبي، أطلق، الرواة، الخلاف، يقض، الكاشف).

This research is concerned with collecting and studying the narrators about whom Imam al-Dhahabi narrated something different from the imams of al-Jarh and Ta’deel before him, and he did not clarify his final ruling on them in his book Al-Kashef in Knowing Who Has a Narration in the Six Books, and coming up with a final conclusion regarding these narrators, and their number in this part has reached twenty narrators.

Keywords : (Al-Dhahabi, released, the narrators, the dispute, eliminates, the revealer).

Bibliography

1.       Al-Ism???l?, A?mad bin Ibr?h?m. "Mu?jam F? As?m? Shuy?kh Ab? Bakr Al-Ism???l?". Investigated by: Ziad Muhammad, (1st Edition, Al-Uloum wa Al-Hikam Library, Madinah, 1410 AH).

2.       Al-A?bah?n?, A?mad bin ?Abdull?h. "Al-Musnad Al-Mustakhraj ?al? ?a??? Al-Im?m Muslim". Investigated by: Muhammad Hassan Al-Shafei, (Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, N. D, N. E).

3.       Al-A?bah?n?, A?mad bin ?Abdull?h. "Musnad Ab? ?an?fah". Investigation: Nazr Al-Faryabi, (1st Edition, Al-Kawthar Library, Riyadh, 1415 AH).

4.       Al-A?bah?n?, Mu?ammad bin Ibr?h?m Ibn al-Muqri?. "Al-Mu?jam Li-Ibn Al-Muqri?". Investigated by: Adel bin Saad, (1st Edition, Al-Rushd Library, Riyadh, 1419 AH).

5.       Al-An??r?, ?Umar ibn ?Al? bin al-Mulaqqin. "Al-Badr Al-Mun?r F? Takhr?j Al-A??d?th Wa-Al-?th?r Al-W?qi?ah F? Al-Shar? Al-Kab?r". Investigated by: Mustafa Aboul Gheit and others, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Hijrah for Publishing and Distribution, Riyadh, 1425 AH).

6.       Al-An??r?, Mu?ammad bin Mukarram Ibn Man??r. "Lis?n al-?Arab". (3rd Edition, Dar Sader, Beirut, 1414 AH).

7.       Bukhari, Muhammad bin Isma'il. "Al-Adab Al-Mufra". Edited by: Samir Al-Zuhairi, (Ma’arif Library, Riyadh, N.D.).

8.       Bukhari, Muhammad bin Isma'il. "Al-T?r?kh Al-Kab?r". (N.E., Ottoman Education Bureau, Hyderabad, N.  D.).

9.       Al-Bukh?r?, Mu?ammad bin Ism???l. "Al-J?mi? Al-Musnad Al-?a??? Al-Mukhta?ar Min Um?r Ras?l All?h  Wa Sunanih Wa-Ayy?mih". Investigated by: Muhammad Zuhair bin Nasser Al-Nasser, (1st Edition, Dar Tuq Al-Najat illustrated from the Sultaniya by adding the numbering of Muhammad Fouad Abdul Baqi 1422 AH).

10.   Al-Barq?n?, A?mad bin Mu?ammad Ab? Bakr. "Su??l?t Al-Barq?n? Lil-D?raqu?n? Riw?yah Al-Kuraj? ?anhu". Investigated by: Abdul Rahim Muhammad Ahmad Al-Qushayri, (1st Edition, Khaneh Jamili Books Lahore, Pakistan, 1404 AH).

11.   Al-Bazz?r, A?mad bin ?Amr. "Musnad al-Bazz?r". Investigated by: Mahfouz Al-Rahman and others, (Science Library, Medina, N.D.).

12.   Al-Busti, Muhammad bin Habban. "Al-Thiq?t". (1st Edition, Ministry of Education of the Indian High Government, Hyderabad, 1393 AH).

13.   Al-Bust?, Mu?ammad bin ?ibb?n. "?a??? Ibn ?ibb?n Bi-Tart?b Ibn Balab?n".. Edited by: Shuaib Al-Arnaout, (2nd Edition, Al-Resala Foundation, Beirut, 1414 AH).

14.   Al-Basri, Ahmad bin Muhammad bin al-'Arabi. "Mu?jam Ibn al-A?r?b?". Investigated by: Abdul Mohsen Ibrahim, (3rd Edition, Dar Ibn Al-Jawzi, Dammam, 1418 AH).

15.   Baghdadi, Ahmad bin Ali bin Thabit. "Al-Kif?yah F? ?ilm Al-Riw?yah". Investigated by: Abu Abdullah Al-Sorqi and Ibrahim Hamdi Al-Madani, (D?r al-Maktabah al-?Ilm?yah, Madinah, N. D.).

16.   Baghdadi, Ahmad bin Ali bin Thabit. "T?r?kh Baghd?d". Investigated by: Dr. Bashar Awad, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Gharb Al-Islami, Beirut, 1422 AH).

17.   Baghdadi, Ahmad bin Ali bin Thabit. "Sharaf A???b Al-?ad?th". Investigated by: Muhammad Sa’eed, (D?r I?y?? al-Sunnah, Ankara).

18.   Al-Baghd?d?, ?abd Al-Ra?m?n bin ?al? Bin Al-Jawz?. "Al-?u?af?? Wa-Al-Matr?k?n". Investigated by: Abdullah Al-Qadi, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, 1406 AH).

19.   Al-Baghd?d?, ?Abd Al-Malik bin Mu?ammad bin Bishr?n. "Am?l? Ibn Bishr?n". Investigated by: Ahmed Suleiman, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Watan, Riyadh, 1420 AH).

20.   Al-Baghd?d?, ?Umar bin A?mad bin Sh?h?n. "T?r?kh Asm?? Al-Thiq?t". Edited by: Sobhi Al-Samarrai, (1st Edition, Al-Dar Al-Salafiya, 1404 AH, N. D.).

21.   Al-Baghd?d?, ?Umar bin A?mad bin Sh?h?n. "Dhikr Man Ikhtalafa Al-?Ulam?? Wa-Nuqq?d Al-?ad?th F?hi". Investigated by: Hammad Al-Ansari, (1st Edition, Adwa' Al-Salaf Library, Riyadh, 1419 AH).

22.   Al-Baghd?d?, Mu?ammad bin ?abd Al-Ghan? bin Nuq?ah. "Ikm?l Al-Ikm?l". Investigated by: Abdul Qayyum Abd Rab Al-Nabi, (1st Edition, um Al-Qura University, Makkah Al-Mukarramah, 1410 AH).

23.   Albik?iry, Mughlu??y ibn Qal?j ibn ?Abdull?h. "Ikm?l Tahdh?b Al-Kam?l F? Asm?? Al-Rij?l". Investigated by: Abi Abd al-Rahman Adel bin Muhammad, and Abu Muhammad Osama bin Ibrahim, (1st Edition, Al-Farouk Al-Haditha for Printing and Publishing, Beirut, 1422 AH).

24.   Tirmidhi, Muhammad bin Isa bin Sawrah. "Sunan al-Tirmidhi". Investigated by Bashar Awad Maarouf, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Gharb Al-Islami, Beirut, 1998 AD).

25.   Tirmidhi, Muhammad bin Isa bin Surah. "?ilal Al-Tirmidh? Al-?agh?r". Investigated by: Ahmed Muhammad Shaker, et al., (1st Edition, D?r I?y?? al-Tur?th al-?Arab?, Beirut, 1409 AH).

26.   Tirmidhi, Muhammad bin Isa bin Surah. "?ilal Al-Tirmidh? Al-Kab?r"". Investigated by: Sobhi Al-Samarrai and others, (1st Edition, Alam Al-Kutub, Beirut, 1409 AH).

27.   al-Jurj?n?, ?Abdull?h bin ?Adiy, "Al-K?mil F? ?u?af?? Al-Rij?l". Investigated by: Adel Abdel Mawjoud and others, 1st Edition, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, 1418 AH).

28.   Al-Jazari, Ali bin Abi Al-Karam Muhammad. "Al-Lub?b F? Tahdh?b Al-Ans?b". (Beirut, Dar Sader, N.D., N. E).

29.   Al-Jam?l?, Q?sim bin Qu?l?bagh?. "Al-Thiq?t Mimman Lam Yaqa?u F? Al-Kutub Al-Sittah". Investigation by: Shadi bin Muhammad bin Salem Al Numan, (1st Edition, Al-Numan Center for Research and Islamic Studies, Yemen, 1432 AH).

30.   Al-Hanbali, Muhammad 'Abd al-Ghani bin Nuqta. "Al-Taqy?d Li-Ma?rifat Ruw?t Al-Sunan Wa-Al-Mas?n?d". Investigated by: Kamal Al-Hout, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, 1408 AH).

31.   Al-Khalal, al-Hasan bin Muhammad. "Al-Maj?lis Al-?asharah Al-Am?l? Lil-?asan Al-Khall?l". Investigated by: Majdy Fathy, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Sahaba, Tanta, 1411 AH).

32.   Al-Daraqutni, 'Ali bin 'Umar. "Al-?u?af?? Wa-Al-Matr?k?n". Investigated by: Abdul Rahim Al-Qashqari, (1st Edition, Journal of the Islamic University, Al-Madinah Al-Munawwarah, 1403 AH).

33.   Al-Daraqutni, 'Ali bin 'Umar. "Sunan al-Daraqutni". Edited by: Shuaib Al-Arnaout, (1st Edition, Al-Resala Foundation, Beirut, 1424 AH).

34.   Al-Daraqutni, 'Ali bin 'Umar. "Su??l?t Al-??kim Al-N?s?b?r? Lil-D?raqu?n?". Investigated by: Dr.  Muwaffaq bin Abdullah bin Abdul Qadir, (1st edition, Al-Maaref Library, Riyadh, 1404 AH).

35.   Al-Dimashq?, ?Al? bin al-?asan bin Hibatull?h Ibn ?As?kir. "T?r?kh Dimashq".. Edited by: Amr Al-Omari, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Fikr, Beirut 1415 AH).

36.   Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Uthman. "Al-?Ibar F? Khabar Min Ghabar". Investigated by: Muhammad Al-Saeed Zaghloul, (Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, N. D, N.E).

37.   Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Uthman. "Al-K?shif F? Ma?rifat Min La-Hu Riw?yah F? Al-Kutub Al-Sittah" Investigated by: Muhammad Awamah and Ahmed Muhammad Al-Khatib, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Qibla for Islamic Culture, Jeddah, 1413 AH).

38.   Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Uthman. "Al-Mughn? F? Al-?u?af??". Investigated by: Noureddine Ater, (1st Edition, Department of Revival of Islamic Heritage, Qatar, N. D).

39.   Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Uthman. "T?r?kh Al-Isl?m Wawafy?t Al-Mash?h?r W?l??l?m". Investigated by: Dr. Bashar Awad Maarouf, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Gharb Al-Islami, Beirut, 2003).

40.   Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Uthman. "Tadhkirat Al-?uff??".. (1st Edition, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, 1419 AH - 1998 AD).

41.   Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Uthman. "Siyar A?l?m Al-Nubal??". Investigated by: Shuaib Al-Arnaout and others, (3rd Edition, Al-Resala Foundation, Beirut, 1405 AH).

42.   Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Uthman. ""M?z?n Al-I?tid?l F? Naqd Al-Rij?l". Investigated by: Ali Muhammad Al-Bejawi, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Marefa for Printing and Publishing, Beirut, 1382 AH).

43.   Al-Razi, 'Abd al-Rahman bin Muhammad bin Abi Hatim. "Al-Jar? Wa-Al-Ta?d?l". (1st Edition, Edition of the Ottoman Education Bureau, India, 1271 AH).

44.   Al-Razi, 'Abd al-Rahman bin Muhammad bin Abi Hatim. "?ilal Al-?ad?th". Investigated by: Moheb al-Din al-Khatib, (Dar al-Maarifa, Beirut, 1405 AH, N. E.).

45.   Al-Zirikl?, Khayr al-D?n bin Ma?m?d. "al-A?l?m". (15th edition, Dar Al-Malayin, N.D.).

46.   Al-Sijist?n?, Sulaym?n bin al-Ash?ath Ab? D?w?d. "Sunan Ab? D?w?d" Investigated by: Muhammad Mohieddin, (N. D, N. P).

47.   Al-Sakh?w?, Mu?ammad bin ?Abd al-Ra?m?n. "Fat? Al-Mugh?th Bi-Shar? Alf?yat Al-?ad?th Lil-Iraqi". Achieved by: Ali Hussein, (Egypt, Al-Sunnah Library, 1424 AH, d. I).

48.   Al-Sa?d?, ?Al? bin ?Abdill?h Ibn al-Mad?n?. "Su??l?t Ibn Ab? Shaybah Li-?al? Ibn Al-Mad?n?". Investigated by: Muwaffaq Abdullah, (1st Edition, Ma’?rif Library, Riyadh, 1404 AH).

49.   Al-Sam??n?, ?Abd Al-Kar?m bin Mu?ammad bin Man??r. "Al-Ans?b". Investigated by: Abdullah Omar Al-Baroudi, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Jinan, 1408 AH).

50.   Alsahmy, ?amzah ibn Y?suf. "Su??l?t ?amzah Alsahmy". Investigated by: Muwaffaq bin Abdullah bin Abdul Qadir, (1st Edition, Al-Maaref Library, Riyadh, 1404 AH).

51.   Al-Suyuti, 'Abd al-Rahman bin Abi Bakr. "Alf?yat Al-Suy??? F? ?ilm Al-?ad?th". Investigated by: Ahmed Shaker, (N. E, Al-Maktabah Al-‘Ilmiyyah, N. D).

52.   Al-Suyuti, 'Abd al-Rahman bin Abi Bakr. "Tadr?b Al-R?w? F? Shar? Taqr?b Al-Naw?w?".. Investigated by: Abu Qutayba Nazar Muhammad Al-Farbani, (Dar Taiba, N. D, N. P).

53.   Al-Suyuti, 'Abd al-Rahman bin Abi Bakr. "?abaq?t Al-?uff??". (1st Edition, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, 1403 AH).

54.   Al-Shayb?n?, A?mad bin Mu?ammad bin ?anbal. "Al-?ilal Wa-Ma?rifat Al-Rij?l Riw?yah ?Abdill?h". Invetsigated by: Wasiyull?h bin Muhammad Abbas, (2nd Edition, Dar Al-Khafi, Riyadh, 1422 AH).

55.   Al-Shayb?n?, A?mad bin Mu?ammad bin ?anbal. Musnad Ahmad ibn Hanbal. Investigated by: Shuaib Al-Arnaout and others, (1st Edition, Al-Resala Foundation, Beirut, 1414 AH).

56.   Al-?afad?, Khal?l bin Aybak. "Al-W?f? Bi-Al-Wafay?t". Edited by: Ahmad Al-Arnaout, (Dr. I, Dar Revival of Heritage, Beirut, 1420 AH).

57.   Al-?Ijl?, A?mad bin ??li?. "Ma?rifat Al-Thiq?t Min Rij?l Ahl Al-?ilm Wa-Al-?ad?th Wa-Man Al-?u?af?? Wa-Dhikr Madh?hibahum Wa-Akhb?ruhum". Achieved by: Abd al-Alim Abd al-Azim al-Bastawi, (1st Edition, Al-Dar Library, Medina, 1405 AH).

58.   Al-?Ijl?, ?Al? ibn Hibatill?h Ibn M?k?l?. "Al-Ikm?l F? Raf? Al-Irtiy?b ?an Al-Mu?talif W?lmkhtlf F? Al-Asm?? Wa-Al-Kun? Wa-Al-Ans?b". (1st Edition, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, Beirut, 1411 AH).

59.   Al-?Ir?q?, ?Abd al-Ra??m ibn al-?usayn. "Al-Taqy?d Wa-Al-???? Shar? Muqaddimah Ibn Al-?al??". Investigated by: Abdul Rahman Muhammad Othman, (1st Edition 1389 AH, D. M, D. N).

60.   Al-?Asqal?n?, A?mad bin ?Al? bin ?ajar. "Al-Dir?yah F? Takhr?j A??d?th Al-Hid?yah". Edited by: Mr. Abdullah Al-Madani, (Dar Al-Maarifa, Beirut, N. D., N. P.).

61.   Al-?Asqal?n?, A?mad bin ?Al? bin ?ajar. "Taqr?b Al-Tahd?b". (2nd Edition, Dar Al-Resala Al-Alamiyya, Beirut, 1435 AH - 2014 AD).

62.   Al-?Asqal?n?, A?mad bin ?Al? bin ?ajar. "Tahd?b Al-Tahd?b". (1st Edition, Nizamuye Education Bureau, India, 1326 AH).

63.   Al-?Asqal?n?, A?mad bin ?Al? bin ?ajar. "Fath al-Bari Sharh Sahih al-Bukhari". (Dar Al-Maarifa, Beirut, 1379 AH, d.i).

64.   Al-?Asqal?n?, A?mad bin ?Al? bin ?ajar. "Lis?n Al-M?z?n". Investigation: Nizamuye Education Bureau, (2nd Edition, Al-Alami Foundation for Publications, Beirut, Beirut, 1390 AH).

65.   Al-?Uqail?, Mu?ammad bin ?Amr Ibn M?s?. "Al-?u?af?? Al-Kab?r". Edited by: Abdel Muti Amin Kalaji, (1st Edition, D?r Al-Maktabah Al-‘Ilmiyyah, Beirut, 1404 AH).

66.   al-Ghattafani, Yahya bin Zakariya bin Ma'een. "T?r?kh Ibn Ma?een, Bi-Riw?yat Al-D?r?"., Narrated by Al-Douri". Investigated by: Ahmed Muhammad Nour Saif, (1st Edition, Center for Scientific Research and Revival of Islamic Heritage, Makkah Al-Mukarramah, 1399 AH).

67.   Al-Ghattafani, Yahya ibn Zakariya ibn Mu'in. "T?r?kh Ibn Ma?een, Bi-Riw?yat ?uthm?n Al-D?rim?" Investigated by: Ahmed Muhammad Nour Saif, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Mamoun for Heritage, Damascus, 1400 AH).

68.   al-Ghattafani, Yahya ibn Zakariya ibn Ma'een. "Su??l?t Ibn al-Junayd li-Ab? Zakar?y? Ya?y? ibn Ma??n". Investigated by: Ahmed Muhammad Nour Saif, (1st Edition, Al-Dar Library, Medina, 1408 AH).

69.   Al-F?ris?, ?Al? bin Bilb?n. "Al-I?s?n F? Taqr?b ?a??? Ibn ?ibb?n". Investigated by: Shuaib Al-Arnaout, (1st Edition, Al-Resala Foundation, Beirut, 1408 AH).

70.   Al-F?s?, ?Al? Ibn Mu?ammad bin Al-Qa???n. "Bay?n Al-Wahm Wa-Al-?h?m F? Kit?b Al-A?k?m". Investigated by: Al-Hussein, Ait Saeed, (1st Edition, Dar Taibah, Riyadh, 1418 AH).

71.   Al-Mizz?, Y?suf bin ?Abd Al-Ra?m?n. "Tahdh?b Al-Kam?l F? Asm?? Al-Rij?l". Investigated by: Dr. Bashar Awad Maarouf, (1st Edition, Al-Resala Foundation, Beirut, 1400 AH).

72.   Al-Mu?allim?, ?Abd al-Ra?m?n bin Ya?y?. "Al-Tank?l Bi-M? F? Ta?n?b Al-Kawthar? Min Al-Ab???l". (2nd Edition, Islamic Office, Beirut, 1406 AH).

73.   Al-Maqdis?, Mu?ammad bin ?Abd al-W??id. "Al-A??d?th Al-Mukht?rah Mimm? Lam Yukharrijhu Al-Bukh?r? Wa-Muslim F? ?a???ayhim?". Edited by: Dr. Abdul Malik bin Abdullah Dahish, (1st Edition, Dar Khader for Printing and Publishing, Beirut, 1420 AH - 2000 AD).

74.   An-Nasa'i, Ahmad ibn Shu'ayb. "Al-?u?af?? Wa-Al-Matr?k?n". Investigated by: Mahmoud Ibrahim Zayed, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Wa'i, Aleppo, 1396 AH).

75.   Al-Namr?, Y?suf bin ?abd All?h Ibn ?abd Al-Barr. "Al-Tamh?d Li-M? F? Al-Muwa??a? Min Al-Ma??n? Wa-Al-As?n?d".. Edited by: Mustafa Alaoui, (Ministry of Awqaf, Morocco, 1387 AH, N. E).

76.   Al-Namr?, Y?suf bin ?abd All?h Ibn ?abd Al-Barr.  "J?mi? Bay?n Al-?ilm Wa-Fa?lihi".. Invetsigated by: Abu Al-Ashbal Al-Zuhairi, (1st Edition, Riyadh, Dar Ibn Al-Jawzi, 1414 AH).

77.   Al-Nawawi, Yahya bin Sharaf. "Al-Majm?? Shar? Al-Muhadhdhab". (Dar Al-Fikr, N. D, N. E).

78.   An-Nisaburi, Muhammad bin Ishaq ibn Khuzaymah. "Sahih Ibn Khuzaymah". Investigated by: Muhammad Mustafa Al-Adhami, (Islamic Office, Beirut, N. D, N. E).

79.   An-Naysaburi, Muhammad bin 'Abdullah al-Hakim. "Al-Mustadrak ?al? Al-?a???ayn". Investigated by: Mustafa Abdel Qader Atta, (1st Edition, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, 1411 AH).

80.   An-Naysaburi, Muhammad bin 'Abdullah al-Hakim. "T?r?kh Nais?b?r". (N. E., N.D., N. P)

81.   An-Naysaburi, Muhammad bin 'Abdullah al-Hakim. "Ma’rifat ‘Ul?m Al-?ad?th". Investigated by: Al-Sayyid Moazzam Hussein, (2nd Edition, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, 1397 AH).

82.   Al-Nays?b?ri, Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj. "Sahih Muslim". Investigated by: Mohamed Fouad Abdel Baqi, (D?r I?y? Al-Tur?th Al-‘Arab?, Beirut, N. D N. E).

83.   Al-Haythami, 'Ali ibn Abi Bakr. "Majma? Al-Zaw??id Wa-Manba? Al-Faw??id". Investigated by: Hossam al-Din al-Qudsi, (Al-Qudsi Library, Cairo, 1414 AH).