وصيَّة النبي ع بطلاب العلم

- دراسة حديثيَّة تحليليَّة -

The Recommendation of the Prophet, ( peace & blessings be upon him), for the Seekers of Knowledge

- Prophet's Hadith, Analytical Study -

عنوان البحث: وصية النبي ع بطلاب العلم -  دراسة حديثية تحليلية -.

موضوع البحث وأهميته: دراسة وصية النبي ع بطلاب العلم، وتخريجها، وبيان الفوائد المستخرجة منها، وذلك يبين عناية الإسلام بالعلم وطلابه.

منهج البحث: المنهج التحليلي، والاستقرائي وفق الإجراءات المتبعة في علم الحديث.

أهم نتائج البحث:

1-روى وصية النبي ع بطلاب العلم أربعة من الصحابة: أبوسعيد الخدري، وأبو هريرة، وجابر، وأبو الدرداء، ش، وترجح للباحث أن الوصية حسنة بمجموع طرقها التالية:

2-أما أبو سعيد س فرويت عنه من أربع طرق:

أ‌-طريق أبي هارون العبدي، وهي ضعيفة جدا، لحال أبي هارون العبدي.

ب‌-طريق أبي نضرة وهي أقوى طرقه ولأجلها صحح الحديث من صححه من أهل العلم، وفيها اختلاط الجريري وعدم تمييز سماع الراوي عنه.

ت‌-طريق أبي خالد مولى بني الصباح وفيها راو يحيى الحماني وهو متروك.

ث‌-طريق شهر بن حوشب، في إسنادها ليث ابن أبي سليم ضعيف الحديث.

3-وحديث أبي هريرة، وجابر شديدا الضعف.

4-وحديث أبي الدرداء فيه الراوي عنه ولم يتميز ويتبين للباحث من هو.

5-في الوصية فوائد جليلة مثل فضل العلم والوصية بأهله وطلابه، وأن الرحلة فيه من طرق طلبه، وفضل الصحابة والتابعين، وما ينبغي من الرفق بطلاب العلم وتيسير العلم لهم.

الكلمات المفتاحية: (وصية، النبي ع، طلاب، العلم).

The research topic: Studying the recommendation of Prophet, (peace & blessings be upon him), for the seekers of knowledge, determining its sources and explaining the benefits derived from it.

Research Method: The analytical, inductive approach, according to the steps followed in Science of Hadith.

The most important results of the research:

1-The recommendation of the Prophet,( peace & blessings be upon him), for the seekers of knowledge narrated by four of the companions: Abu Sa'id al-Khudri, Abu Hurairah, Jabir, and Abu Ad-Darda, and it has become more likely to the researcher that the recommendation is good with all the following of its chains of narrations:

2-As for Abu Sa'id, it was narrated by him from four chains of narrations:

a. By Abi Harun Al-Abdi, which is very weak, that because of his qualities.

b. By Abi Nadrah, which is the stronger of its chains of narrations, and by this narration, one of the scholars classifies Hadith as good Hadith, this narration included Al-Jariri's confusion, but hearing the Hadith from him by the narrator is not known.

c. By Abi Khalid, Bani As-Sabah's slave, this narration included a narrator, Yahya Al-Hamani, and it is abandoned.

d. By Shahr Bin Hawshab, and in its chain of transmission Leith bin Abi Salim, his narration is weak because of his confusion.

3-Hadith narrated by Abu Hurairah and Hadith narrated by Jabir are very weak.

4-And in a Hadith narrated by Abu Ad-Darda, the narrator who narrated from him was not known.

5-There are great benefits in the recommendation, such as the   virtues of knowledge, the recommending for the scholars and the seekers of knowledge, and traveling to seek knowledge is one of knowledge seeking ways.

Keywords: (Will, Prophet, Students, Science).

Bibliography

1.       Ibrahim Al-Jawzjani. "a?w?l al-rij?l". Investigator: Abdul-Aleem Al-Bastawi. (Faisalabad, Pakistan: Had?th Academy).

2.       Ibn Abi Hatem, Abdul Rahman. "al-jar? wa-al-ta?d?l". (1st edition, Hyderabad Deccan - India: Edition of the Ottoman Encyclopedia Council, Beirut: Dar Ihya’ al-Tarath al-Arabi, 1271 AH).

3.       Ibn al-Atheer, Majd al-Din al-Mubarak. "al-nih?yah f? Ghar?b al-?ad?th wa-al-athar". Investigation: Taher Ahmed Al-Zawy - Mahmoud Muhammad Al-Tanahi. (Beirut: Scientific Library, 1399 AH).

4.       Ibn Al-Junaid, "Su??l?t Ibn al-Junayd ly?y ibn Mu??n". Investigation: Ahmed Muhammad. (1st edition, Al-Dar Library, 1408 AH).

5.       Ibn al-Jawzi, Abdul Rahman. “"al-?ilal al-mutan?hiyah f? al-a??d?th alw?hiyah". (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1403 AH).

6.       Ibn al-Salah, Othman. "ma?rifat ?ul?m al-?ad?th". Investigation: Nour al-Din Anar. (Damascus: Dar Al-Fikr).

7.       Ibn al-Qaysrani, Abu al-Fadl Muhammad. "Dhakh?rat al-?uff?? (min al-k?mil li-Ibn ?Ad?)" Investigator: Dr. Abdul Rahman Al-Fariwai. (Riyadh: Dar Al Salaf).

8.       Ibn al-Muqri, "al-Arba??n". Care and graduation: Muhammad Ziyad Omar Takla. (1st edition, Saudi Arabia: Obeikan Library, 1421 AH).

9.       Ibn al-Muqri, Abu Bakr Muhammad. “"al-th?lith ?ashar min faw??id Ibn al-Muqri?". (1st edition, manuscript published in the free Jami’ al-Kalam program of the Islamic Network website, 2004 AD).

10.   Ibn Hibban, Muhammad. "al-majr???n min al-mu?addith?n wa-al-?u?af?? wa-al-matr?k?n". Investigator: Mahmoud Ibrahim Zayed. (1st edition, Aleppo: Dar Al-Wa’i, 1396 AH).

11.   Ibn Hajar, Ahmed Al-Asqalani. "al-Mu?jam al-mufahras aw Tajr?d as?n?d al-Kutub al-mashh?rah wa-al-ajz?? al-manth?rah". Investigator: Muhammad Shakur Al-Mayadini. (1st edition, Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1418 AH).

12.   Ibn Hamza Al-Husseini, Ibrahim. "al-Bay?n wa-al-ta?r?f f? asb?b Wur?d al-?ad?th al-Shar?f". Investigator: Saif Al-Din Al-Kateb. (Beirut: Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi).

13.   Ibn Hanbal, Ahmed bin Muhammad. "u??l al-Sunnah". Investigation: Al-Walid bin Muhammad. (Cairo: Ibn Taymiyyah Library).

14.   Ibn Khair al-Ishbili, Abu Bakr Muhammad. "Fahrasat". Investigation: Muhammad Fouad Mansour. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1419 AH).

15.   Ibn Rajab, Abd al-Rahman al-Hanbali. "Dhayl ?abaq?t al-?an?bilah". Investigator: Dr. Abdul Rahman Al-Othaimeen. (1st edition, Riyadh: Obeikan Library, 1425 AH).

16.   Ibn Saad, Abu Abdullah Muhammad. "al-?abaq?t al-Kubr?". Investigation: Muhammad Abdel Qader Atta. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1410 AH).

17.   Ibn Shaheen, Omar bin Ahmed. "T?r?kh Asm?? al-?u?af?? wa-al-kadhdh?b?n wa-al-matr?k?n". Investigator: Muhammad Al-Azhari. (1st edition, Cairo: Al-Farouq Al-Hadeeth for Printing and Publishing, 1430 AH).

18.   Ibn Abd al-Barr, Yusuf al-Qurtubi. "J?mi? bay?n al-?Ilm wa-fa?lihi". Investigation: Abu Al-Ashbal Al-Zuhairi. (1st edition, Saudi Arabia: Dar Ibn al-Jawzi, 1414 AH).

19.   Ibn Asakir, Abu Al-Qasim. "Mu?jam al-shuy?kh". Investigator: Dr. Wafa Taqi Al-Din. (1st edition, Damascus: Dar Al-Bashaer, 1421 AH).

20.   Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah, Muhammad Ibn Abi Bakr. "I?l?m al-muwaqqi??n ?an Rabb al-??lam?n". Investigation: Abdul Rahman Al-Wakil. (Cairo: Ibn Taymiyyah Library).

21.   Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah, Muhammad bin Abi Bakr. "Mift?? D?r al-Sa??dah wa-mansh?r Wil?yat al-?Ilm wa-al-ir?dah". (Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah).

22.   Ibn Majah, Muhammad Al-Qazwini. “Sunan Ibn Majah.” Investigator: Shuaib Al-Arnaout - Adel Murshid - Muhammad Kamel Qarabulli - Abdul Latif Harzallah. (1st edition, Dar Al-Resala Al-Alamiah, 1430 AH).

23.   Ibn Ma’in, Yahya. "T?r?kh Ibn Ma??n (riw?yah al-D?r?)". Investigator: Dr. Ahmed Mohamed Nour Saif. (Makkah Al-Mukarramah: Center for Scientific Research and Revival of Islamic Heritage).

24.   Ibn Ma’in, Yahya. "min kal?m Ab? Zakar?y? Ya?y? ibn Mu??n f? al-rij?l (riw?yah ?ahm?n)". Investigation: Dr. Ahmed Mohamed Nour Saif. (Damascus: Dar Al-Mamoun Heritage).

25.   Ibn Mufleh, Muhammad al-Maqdisi. "al-?d?b al-shar??yah wa-al-mina? al-mar??yah". (Beirut: ‘?lam Al-Kutub).

26.   Ibn Mandah, Abu Abdullah Muhammad. "Fat? al-B?b f? al-kun? wa-al-alq?b". Investigator: Abu Qutaybah Nazr Muhammad Al-Faryabi. (1st edition, Riyadh: Al-Kawthar Library, 1417 AH).

27.   Ibn Nuqtah, Muhammad. "Takmilat al-Ikm?l". Investigation: Abd al-Qayyum Abd Rab al-Nabi. (1st edition, Mecca: Umm Al-Qura University, 1408 AH).

28.   Ibn Wahb, Abdullah. "al-Musnad li-?Abd All?h ibn Wahb". Investigator: Mohieddin Al-Bakari. (1st edition, Dar Al-Tawhid for Heritage Revival, 2007 AD).

29.   Abu Dawood, Suleiman Al-Sijistani. “Sunan.” Investigation: Shuaib Al-Arnaout - Muhammad Kamel Qarabelli. (1st edition, Dar Al-Resala Al-Alamiah, 1430 AH).

30.   Abu Dawood, Suleiman Al-Sijistani. "Su??l?t Ab? ?Ubayd al??jry Ab? D?w?d al-Sijist?n? f? al-jar? wa-al-ta?d?l". Investigator: Muhammad Ali Qasim Al-Omari. (1st edition, Medina: Deanship of Scientific Research at the Islamic University, 1403 AH).

31.   Abu Taher Al-Salafi, Ahmed. "al-thal?th?n min al-Mashyakhah al-Baghd?d?yah". (1st edition, manuscript published in the free Jami’ al-Kalam program of the Islamic Network website, 2004 AD).

32.   Al-Ajri, Muhammad bin Al-Hussein. "far? ?ilib al-?Ilm".Investigation and commentary: Ali bin Ahmed bin Hassan Al-Razhi. (1st edition, Riyadh: Al-Ma’rif Library, 1431 AH).

33.   Ahmed Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani. "It??f al-Mahrah bi-al-Faw??id al-mubtakarah min a?r?f al-?asharah". Investigation: Sunnah and Biography Service Center, under the supervision of Dr. Zuhair bin Nasser Al-Nasser. (1st edition, Medina: King Fahd Complex for the Printing of the Noble Qur’an - Center for Service of the Sunnah and the Prophet’s Biography, 1415 AH).

34.   Al-Azdi, Muammar bin Rashid. “Al-Jami’ (published as an appendix to Abd al-Razzaq’s Musannaf).” Investigator: Habib Al-Rahman Al-Adhami. (2nd edition, Pakistan: Scientific Council, 1403 AH).

35.   Al-Asbahani, Abu Naeem Ahmed. "T?r?kh a?bh?n". Investigator: Sayed Kasravi Hassan. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1410 AH).

36.   Al-Asbahani, Abu Naeem Ahmed. "?ilyat al-awliy?? wa-?abaq?t al-a?fiy??". (Egypt: Al-Saada, 1394 AH).

37.   Al-Albani, Muhammad Nasser al-Din. "Silsilat al-a??d?th al-?a???ah wa-shay? min fiqhih? wa-faw??iduh?". (1st edition, Riyadh: Al-Ma’arif Library).

38.   Al-Anbari, Abu Bakr. "al-z?hir f? ma??n? Kalim?t al-n?s". Investigator: Dr. Hatem Saleh Al-Daman. (1st edition, Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1412 AH).

39.   Al-Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail. "al-t?r?kh al-kab?r". (Hyderabad - Deccan: Ottoman Encyclopedia).

40.   Al-Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail. "Sahih Bukhari". Investigator: Muhammad Zuhair bin Nasser Al-Nasser. (1st edition, Dar Touq Al-Najat, 1422 AH).

41.   Al-Barbahari, Al-Hassan bin Ali. "shar? al-Sunnah". Investigation: Khaled Al-Raddadi. (Al-Ghurabaa Archaeological Library, Medina, 1st edition 1414 AH).

42.   Al-Busiri, Abu Al-Abbas. "Mi?b?? al-zuj?jah f? Zaw??id Ibn M?jah". Investigator: Muhammad Al-Muntaqa. (2nd ed., Beirut: Dar Al Arabiya, 1403 AH).

43.   Al-Baydawi, Nasser al-Din Abdullah. "Tu?fat al-abr?r shar? Ma??b?? al-Sunnah". Investigation: A specialized committee under the supervision of Nour El-Din Taleb. (Kuwait: Ministry of Endowments and Islamic Affairs, 1433 AH).

44.   Al-Bayhaqi, Abu Bakr Ahmad. "al-Madkhal il? al-sunan al-Kubr?". Investigator: Dr. Muhammad Zia Rahman Al Azami. (Kuwait: Dar Al-Khalafa for Islamic Books).

45.   Al-Bayhaqi, Abu Bakr Ahmad. "sha?b al-?m?n". Verified by: Dr. Abdul Ali Hamed. (1st edition, Riyadh: Al-Rushd Library for Publishing and Distribution, 1423 AH)

46.   Al-Tirmidhi, Muhammad bin Issa. "Sunan al-Tirmidh?". Investigator: Bashar Maarouf. (Beirut: Dar Al-Gharb Al-Islami, 1998 AD).

47.   Al-Hakim, Abu Ahmed. "al-as?m? wa-al-kun?". Investigator: Youssef bin Muhammad Al-Dakhil. (1st edition, Medina: Dar Al-Ghurabaa for Heritage, 1994 AD).

48.   Al-Hakim, Abu Abdullah Muhammad Al-Naysaburi. "al-Mustadrak ?al? al-?a???ayn". Investigation: Mustafa Abdel Qader Atta. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1411 AH).

49.   Al-Hakim, Abu Abdullah. "ma?rifat ?ul?m al-?ad?th wa-kamm?yat ajn?sih". Investigation: Ahmed Al-Saloum. (1st edition, Beirut: (1st edition, Dar Ibn Hazm, 1424 AH).

50.   Al-Husseini, Dr. Omar bin Muslih. "Mak?nat alssunnah al-Nabaw?yah". (1st edition, Medinah: Islamic University, 1432 AH).

51.   Al-Hakami, Hafez bin Ahmed. "Majm?? al-ras??il wa-al-man??m?t al-?Ilm?yah". Investigation: Muhammad Al-Baidhani. (Al-Kalim Al-Tayyib Library).

52.   Al-Khatib Al-Baghdadi, Abu Bakr Ahmed bin Ali. "al-Faq?h wa almutafaqqih". Investigator: Abu Abd al-Rahman al-Gharazi. (2nd edition, Saudi Arabia: Dar Ibn al-Jawzi, 1421 AH).

53.   Al-Khatib Al-Baghdadi, Abu Bakr Ahmed. "al-J?mi? li-akhl?q al-R?w? wa-?d?b al-s?mi?". Investigator: Muhammad Ajaj Al-Khatib. (2nd edition, Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1414 AH).

54.   Al-Khatib Al-Baghdadi, Abu Bakr Ahmed. "Sharaf a???b al-?ad?th". Investigator: Dr. Mehmet Saeed Hattioglu. (Ankara: House of Revival of the Prophet’s Sunnah).

55.   Al-Khalal, Abu Bakr Ahmed. "al-Muntakhab min al-?ilal". Election: Muwaffaq al-Din Ibn Qudamah al-Maqdisi, investigator: Abu Omar Muhammad bin Ali al-Azhari. (1st edition, Cairo: Al-Farouq Al-Hadeeth Printing and Publishing, 1433 AH).

56.   Al-Daraqutni, Abu Al-Hasan. "al-?u?af?? al-?u?af?? wa-al-matr?k?n". Investigator: Dr. Abdul Rahim Muhammad Al-Qashqari. (Madinah: Journal of the Islamic University).

57.   ??Al-Daraqutni, Ali bin Omar. "Su??l?t al-??kim al-N?s?b?r? lil-D?raqu?n?". Investigator: Dr. Muwaffaq bin Abdullah bin Abdul Qadir. (1st edition, Riyadh: Al-Ma’rif Library, 1404 AH).

58.   Al-Darami, Abu Muhammad Abdullah. "Musnad al-D?rim? al-ma?r?f bi- (Sunan al-D?rim?)". Investigation: Hussein Salim Asad Al-Darani. (1st edition, Saudi Arabia: Dar Al-Mughni for Publishing and Distribution, 1412 AH).

59.   Al-Dajani, Dr. Talal bin Saud. "Maw?rid Ibn ?As?kir f? ta?r?kh Dimashq". (1st edition, Medinah: Islamic University, 1425 AH).

60.   Al-Dimashqi, Tamam bin Muhammad. "al-Faw??id". Investigator: Hamdi Abdel Majeed Al-Salafi. (1st edition, Riyadh: Al-Rushd Library, 1412 AH).

61.   Al-Dhahabi, Abu Abdullah Muhammad. "al-?ibar f? khabar min ghabar". Investigator: Abu Hajar Muhammad Al-Saeed bin Bassiouni Zaghloul. (Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah).

62.   Al-Dhahabi, Abu Abdullah Muhammad. "al-K?shif f? ma?rifat min la-hu riw?yah f? al-Kutub al-sittah". Investigator: Muhammad Awama Ahmed Muhammad Nimr Al-Khatib. (1st edition, Jeddah: Dar Al-Qibla for Islamic Culture - Foundation for Qur’anic Sciences, 1413 AH).

63.   Al-Dhahabi, Abu Abdullah Muhammad. "m?z?n al-i?tid?l f? Naqd al-rij?l". Investigation: Ali Muhammad Al-Bajjawi. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Ma’rifa for Printing and Publishing, 1382 AH).

64.   Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmed. "Conservation ticket." Investigation: Zakaria Amirat. (Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1419 AH).

65.   Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmed. “Biographies of Noble Figures.” Investigation: Shuaib Al-Arnaout and others. (3rd edition, Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1405 AH).

66.   Al-Rafi’i, Abdul Karim. "al-tadw?n f? Akhb?r Qazw?n". Investigator: Aziz Allah Al-Atardi. (Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1408 AH).

67.   Al-Ramahramzi, Abu Muhammad. "al-Mu?addith al-f??il bayna al-R?w? w?lw??y". Investigator: Dr. Muhammad Ajaj Al-Khatib. (3rd ed., Beirut: Dar Al-Fikr, 1404 AH).

68.   Al-Rodani, Muhammad bin Suleiman Al-Maghribi. “The connection of the successor to the connection of the predecessor.” Investigation: Muhammad Hajji. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Gharb Al-Islami, 1408 AH).

69.   Al-Sakhawi, Muhammad. “Jawahir and Pearls in the Translation of Sheikh Al-Islam Ibn Hajar.” Investigation: Ibrahim Bagis Abdel Majeed. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Ibn Hazm, 1419 AH).

70.   Al-Samani, Abdul Karim. “The Chosen One from the Dictionary of Sheikhs.” Study and investigation: Muwaffaq bin Abdullah. (1st edition, Riyadh: Dar Alam al-Kutub, 1417 AH).

71.   Al-Shajri Al-Jurjani, Yahya Al-Murshid Billah. "Ratib Al-Amali Al-Khamisiya". Investigation: Muhammad Hassan. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1422 AH).

72.   Al-Shaybani, Ahmed bin Hanbal. “The predicate.” Investigation: Shuaib Al-Arnaout and others. (1st edition, Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1421 AH).

73.   Al-Sulami, Abu Abdul Rahman. . "Su??l?t al-Sulam? lil-D?raqu?n?" Investigation: A team of researchers under the supervision and care of Dr. Saad bin Abdullah Al-Hamid and Dr. Khaled bin Abdul Rahman Al-Jarisi. (1st edition, 1427 AH).

74.   Al-Shahrazuri, Othman. "ma?rifat ?ul?m al-?ad?th". Investigation: Nour al-Din Anar. (Damascus: Dar Al-Fikr).

75.   Diya al-Din al-Maqdisi, Muhammad bin Abdul Wahid. “Selected Hadiths.” Study and investigation: Dr. Abdul Malik bin Abdullah bin Dahish. (3rd edition, Beirut: Dar Khader for Printing, Publishing and Distribution, 1420 AH).

76.   Tashkubrazadeh, Ahmad. “The key to happiness and the lamp of sovereignty in the subjects of science.” (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1985).

77.   Al-Tabarani, Suleiman. "The Middle Dictionary." Investigation: Tariq bin Awadallah - Abdul Mohsen bin Ibrahim Al-Husseini. (Cairo: Dar Al-Haramain, 1415 AH).

78.   Al-Sanani, Abdul Razzaq bin Hammam. "al-mu?annaf". Investigator: Research Center at Dar Al-Taseer. (1st edition, Cairo: Dar Al-Taseer, 1436 AH).

79.   Al-Sanaani, Muhammad bin Ismail. "al-Tanw?r shar? al-J?mi? al-?agh?r". Investigator: Dr. Muhammad Ishaq Muhammad Ibrahim. (1st edition, Riyadh: Dar Al Salam Library, 1432 AH).

80.   Al-Tabarani, Suleiman. "Musnad alsh?myyn". Investigator: Hamdi bin Abdul Majeed Al-Salafi. (1st edition, Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1405 AH).

81.   Al-Tayalisi, Abu Daoud Suleiman. "Musnad Ab? D?w?d al-?ay?lis?". Investigator: Dr. Muhammad bin Abdul Mohsen Al Turki. (1st edition, Egypt: Dar Hajar, 1419 AH).

82.   Al-Tibi, Al-Hussein bin Abdullah. "shar? al-??b? ?al? Mishk?t al-Ma??b?? al-musamm? bi- (al-K?shif ?an ?aq??iq al-sunan)". Investigator: Dr. Abdul Hamid Hindawi. (Makkah Al-Mukarramah - Riyadh: Nizar Mustafa Al-Baz Library).

83.   Al-Asqalani, Ahmed bin Ali. "Tahdh?b al-Tahdh?b". (1st edition, India: Department of Encyclopedia Press, 1326 AH).

84.   Al-Asqalani, Ahmed. "Taqr?b al-Tahdh?b". Investigator: Muhammad Awama. (1st edition, Syria: Dar Al-Rashid, 1406 AH).

85.   Al-Uqaili, Muhammad bin Amr. "al-?u?af?? al-kab?r". Investigator: Abdel Muti Amin Qalaji. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Maktabah Al-Ilmiyya, 1404 AH).

86.   Al-Ala’i, Khalil bin Kaykeldi. "Bughyat al-multamis f? sb??y?t ?ad?th al-Im?m M?lik ibn Anas". Investigation: Hamdi Al-Salafi. (1st edition, Beirut: Alam al-Kutub, 1405 AH).

87.   Al-Kattani, author: Abu Abdullah Muhammad. "al-Ris?lah al-musta?rafah li-bay?n Mashh?r kutub al-Sunnah al-musharrafah". Investigator: Muhammad Al-Muntaser bin Muhammad Al-Zamzami. (6th edition, Dar Al-Bashaer Al-Islamiyyah, 1421 AH).

88.   Al-Mubarakfouri, Abu Al-Ala Muhammad. "Tu?fat al-A?wadh? bi-shar? J?mi? al-Tirmidh?". (Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah).

89.   Al-Mubarakfouri, Ubaidullah. "Mur??t al-maf?t?? shar? Mishk?t al-Ma??b??". (3rd edition, India: Al-Jami’ah Al-Salafiyya, 1404 AH).

90.   Al-Mazzi, Abu Al-Hajjaj Yusuf. “"Tahdh?b al-kam?l f? Asm?? al-rij?l". Investigator: Dr. Bashar Ma’r?f. (1st edition, Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1400 AH).

91.   Al-Ma?hari, Al-Hussein. "al-maf?t?? f? shar? al-Ma??b??". Investigation: A specialized committee under the supervision of: Nour El-Din Taleb. (1st edition, Dar Al-Nawader, 1433 AH).

92.   Muslim, Ibn al-Hajjaj al-Qushayri. "Sahih Muslim". Investigation: Muhammad Fouad Abdel Baqi. (Beirut: Arab Heritage Revival House).

93.   Maghalatai, Ibn Qalij al-Masry. “"Ikm?l Tahdh?b al-kam?l f? Asm?? al-rij?l". Investigator: Adel bin Muhammad - Osama bin Ibrahim. (Al-Farouq Modern Printing and Publishing).

94.   Al-Manawi, Muhammad Abdel Raouf. "al-Tays?r bi-shar? al-J?mi? al-?agh?r". (3rd edition, Riyadh: Imam Al-Shafi’i Library, 1408 AH).

95.   Al-Manawi, Zain al-Din Muhammad. "Fay? al-qad?r shar? al-J?mi? al-?agh?r". (1st edition, Egypt: The Great Commercial Library, 1356 AH).

96.   Al-Mundhiri, Abdul-Azim bin Abdul-Qawi. "Enticement and intimidation." Investigation: Ibrahim Shams Al-Din. (1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1417 AH).

97.   Al-Nasa’i, Ahmed. "al-?u?af?? wa-al-matr?k?n". Investigator: Mahmoud Ibrahim Zayed. (1st edition, Aleppo: Dar Al-Wa’i, 1396 AH).

98.   Al-Nawawi, Yahya bin Sharaf. “Al-Majmu’ Sharh Al-Muhadhdhab.” Investigation: A committee of scholars. (Cairo: Brotherly Solidarity Press, 1347 AH).

99.   Al-Harawi, Abu Ismail. "Dhamm al-kal?m wa-ahlih". Investigator: Abdullah Al-Ansari. (1st edition, Al-Ghurabaa Archaeological Library, 1419 AH).

100.                      Al-Haythami, Ali bin Abi Bakr. "The complex of excesses and the source of benefits." Investigation: Husam al-Din al-Qudsi. (Cairo: Al-Maqdisi Library, 1414 AH).

101.                      Al-Yahsbi, Ayyad. "al?lm?? il? ma?rifat u??l al-riw?yah wa-taqy?d al-sam??". Investigation: Ahmed Saqr. (Cairo: Dar Al-Turath).